Posts Tagged ‘taubes’

Alan Aragon-Girth Control-A Review


23 Jun

I’m going to admit I’ve been guilty of skimming books. I read, and I read A LOT.

When I was about 11 years old I remember that infomercial sweater guy who had a speed reading course on his amazing discovery “show,” and I wanted it soooo bad. Needless to say I didn’t get it, but I did learn to read pretty fast anyway. Sometimes I read too fast and sometimes there were books you just can’t read that fast at all.

Enter Alan Aragon’s Girth Control: The Science Of Fat Loss and Muscle Gain.

Alan Aragon is by far one of the coolest guys I have never met. I have had the pleasure of talking to him a few times and can assure you that he is as smart as he is, and he also “get’s it.” That’s a rare quality. Most who are really smart like that miss the boat. They don’t “get it” and they can’t communicate with people. Instead, they just end up talking in a gibberish that only 10 other “smart people” can understand. It becomes an intellectual pissing contest if you will. It’s sad to see, but a bit funny to watch.

You don’t get that with Alan. However, this post isn’t about him really, this is about Girth.

The first time I read Girth I would call it “more grazing.” I saw enough to know that I would like it if I REALLY read it.

I got the urge to read it again, and really read it. Maybe I’m just smarter or maybe it’s just that I am dying for quality information but it was a heck of a great read the second time around.

First, who is this book for?

Currently, my readers right now are a bit all over the map, and I will be honest that for some of you the beginning aspect of this book may be too technical at first. However, I encourage you to push those boundaries of knowledge comfort anyways. Sometimes it’s a good thing to challenge your ability to learn. That is not to say that this is fat loss rocket science, I’m simply noting that some parts are advanced in discussion (i.e. scientific).

I will say if you’re a trainer and you want to be worth a grain of salt, you will buy this book. And if you ever read the phrase “studies show” and it actually means something to you, then you should buy this book.

Most of the world does not realize what a study is and how flawed they are in general yet many will make really important daily life choices because of them, or worse because of press summaries of those same studies. That can be a very dangerous thing for your ability to choose your own destiny and to go outside of that box that you have stuck yourself in.

If you ever want to free yourself of relying on the words of others, if you ever want to provide yourself with the ability to be the ones “in the know” then this is one hell of a place to start. This is the kind of book Taubes wishes he could write.

“With bills to pay and/or mouths to feed, scientists aren’t magically exempt from the many temptations and the guerrilla tactics of doing business.”

The first three chapters teach you how to understand research on a level of the technical and, even better, how to form opinion from scientific observations. These first sections are the ultimate lesson in study do’s, dont’s and they did what’s?

After that you get into the bulk of the book which is the teaching of what proteins, carbs, and fats really are and why we have the feelings and theories behind them that we do.

Is GI index really important?

What kind of role does insulin really play on fat loss?

How much protein do we really need?

How are fats changing the way we look at health?

One of my favorite parts of the book is the insertion of studies. While it may seem at first glance that Alan keeps the reading buried a bit too deep in data, you have to look between the lines a little bit and see that sometimes he is downright exposing hypocrisy and the ridiculous acts of our government and the lives of other cultures. Point being, it’s only dry if you don’t see the work for what it is: an exposure.

“I’ve always felt that Mother Nature winced every time a yolk hit the waste basket. Having scoured the research, it’s comforting to know that my gut feeling on the issue has a fair amount of support.”

Following that statement are some great study highlights about the effects of yolks on our health. I don’t know if any of you read the recent headlines about how eating eggs will kill you, but Alan can easily show you not only is this not the case but also, again, how to read an actual study and see it’s flaws.

There is also some talk of supplements in Girth, what they do, and if you need them. A book that saves some money in your pocket is always a good read as the majority of us are always walking to GNC.

Alan finishes out the book with what you need to do to achieve either fat loss or muscle gain on a optimum and successful level. This is where his information, for the most part, is a pretty easy read. He covers some great topics from fasting, pre/post workout nutrition, interval training, and the bodies ability to adapt to dieting down.

“The body is simply doing its job as an adaptive survival unit when a plateau occurs. When you stop to think about it, the ultimate goal is to plateau!”

Obviously my focus is on fat loss, and, well, technically Alan is my competition but what can I say, the man does his job and he does it well. If you already have my books (’cause you know you should) then why not add Alan’s to the collection as well? Never be afraid to learn more, never be afraid to keep diving deep. There are few of us out there in the world who don’t like to be told what to think and do. I think this is why I liked Girth so much; I like those who scream against the crowd.

It’s safe to say that Girth delivers on the knowledge front. I hope you take a chance and believe in your ability of thought and give it a shot as well. Always strive to put knowledge in your own hands because that’s the true way to lead to a new life.

Knowledge is fat loss power.

To get Girth go check out Alan’s site at www.alanaragon.com.

And if you want to DOUBLE your learning efforts take 10 lousy bucks ($10 USD) and sign up for his research review as well. (Click Below)

Good Calories, Bad Calories: Idiot’s Guide to Carbohydrates Pt. 2


12 Jan

The Holes

Gary’s biggest mistake is not understanding the ability of human error in measurement of calorie consumption. All it takes is 100 extra calories a day to gain 10lbs in 1 year. That is it. Introduce me to 10 people you know that weigh and measure their food (not in measuring cups either because that is largely flawed). You can’t give me 10, even if you are largely involved in fitness and health. You can’t give me 10 who weigh and measure their food. Now Gary says, “Lean people will often insist that the secret to their success is eating in moderation, but many fat people insist that they eat no more than the lean-surprising as it seems, the evidence backs this up-and yet are fat nonetheless.”

I call bull. And here is why.

The Genetically Gifted

I have talked about this before and I have gone on and on in the new edition of the Troubleshoot about it. You often hear people talk about, and even myself in the past, about the genetically gifted. Let me explain briefly who that is and why chances are if you are reading this that you are not one of them.

Who we dub “gifted” is the guy with the six-pack abs who just chugged down loads of beer after killing off a 16″ inch pizza. The girl who can eat a burger and fry combo and never gain a pound of fat and has a perky bum. They don’t kill themselves in the gym, yet they are cut and lean and have a general good bit of strength. The men have healthy testosterone levels and a statue-like look and the women are bouncing with estrogen features and good beauty. They are the people you hate, they are the gifted.

The reason you hate them may not be the area you think.

They don’t have fast metabolisms, they don’t burn fat faster, this isn’t about being a mesmomorph or about having a hot mommy and daddy (well that could help actually). The point is that it isn’t about how they break down what they eat so much as understanding the fuel they need. The genetically-gifted merely understand one thing by INSTINCT that you do not. They understand naturally when they are in a positive or negative energy state and they eat/feed, and train accordingly if need.

That’s it.

That is what it means to be genetically gifted. You simply understand the energy needs of your body naturally without having to test out activity level, exercise, caloric timing, carb sensitivity, all that crap that the average person doesn’t need to know about. All they really need to know, all you really need to know or do is listen to your body.

Can this function of “hearing” what your body needs be disrupted by a faulty communications system? Yes, it can very much. Can fast-acting refined sugars give you a false sense of alarm in this feed system and throw of your internal sensors if you are genetically predisposed to not listening well to your body? Yes. This is where Taubes gets it right, but again he is missing the bigger picture. The problem of fat gain is still excess energy, period. It does not matter what is wrong with your system, it does not matter how bad your system functions, it is still excess energy that is the blame.

Let me explain further.

Let us say that your body should by all accounts need 2,000 calories a day to stay the weight you are. That is SHOULD by all accounts because of height, weight, age, etc., burn 2,000 calories a day. You take some online quiz and it tells you that, yes, 2,000 calories a day is your limit. Well what if it’s really 1,800 calories a day you are burning? That is a 20 lb gain in 1 year if you ate at 2,000 calories a day. Are you getting the picture yet Taubes? It’s not as complicated as some study in the deep reaches of Africa may suggest.

Now what slows metabolic rates? This is a whole other story. This is where all the fun stuff comes in from hormone dysfunction to thyroid problems and more. IF, and let me state that most don’t, but IF you have a problem then your energy expenditure and burning system is off and your energy level is very low. This could mean that you think 2,000 calories is your burn level but in reality it is 800 calories, now this is a extreme, extreme case but if so then that is a gain of 125lbs in 1 year if you consume that 2,000 calories a day. So if you have a metabolic dysfunction then, yes, you can eat the same amount as that of a lean person but still gain weight. How often does someone ACTUALLY have one of these metabolic dysfunctions? It’s very rare.

The True Killer of Fat Loss

I make the big bucks not because I am some all amazing guru, not because I understand how a carbohydrate breaks down in the body, not because I understand hormone production, but because I convince people to go to their local Target and pick up a digital food scale and finally take into account and get hit in the face with how much they eat in a day. That my friends is how come I make the big bucks, that is why I have earned the title of “There is no one I can’t get to lose fat.” I hold people accountable for what it is they put in their mouth.

I want you to take a look at the video below for a rude awakening of the difference that it makes to just measure your food by digital scale.

So you can see that it is the high starch, full fat items and your personal denial that bring about the worse miss-measure of your caloric intake. Just that being off, if taken into account over a year, is 34lbs of finger pointing fat gain.

Why Protein is Never the Victim of a Lynch Mob

The reason protein is never the victim of a witch hunt style attack is very simple. If you are choosing lean proteins like chicken, turkey, or egg whites how much can you really mess it up? If you are off by a few grams with protein its nothing, its chump changes in calories. Same thing goes for something like broccoli or spinach. These are very low calorically dense foods, any smart health professional knows that by putting you on a high protein/high veg diet just up their chance of getting you to succeed in your fat loss journey, not because of magical thermic processes and not because carbs are the ultimate of evil. It is because it’s hard for you to mess it up! As a society we lack really basic common sense.

I have reason to believe that Taubes is smart enough to know better and it is this reason alone why I get angry at this book because no matter how you slice it (no carb pun intended) fat loss success always rests in the land of energy in and out. You may not like your in and out, your in and out may have a dysfunction, but that is how the carb finger pointing crumbles my friends.

Let us also not ignore the fact that eating low carb or keto for a long-term basis can do real damage to that hormone and information system that you need to start listening too. It is safe to say that while Taubes and many of his followers and believers want to crucify the use of carbohydrates they do not make clear that extremes on both ends are bad. This is likely to cause worse problems for those who bodies will force them back to eating carbs but now due to absence will have poor enzyme and hormone production. THUMBS UP for that one!

Hunger And Exercise

One of the funniest aspects of the book is Taubes take on exercise and his observation with the fact that exercise increases hunger. Well, um, yeah your point being? Exercise is going to increase your caloric deficit, meaning it is going to start you on the track towards burning your stored fuel sources. This is without a doubt going to cause you to be hungry. What you do with that hunger is up to you. If you are in need of losing fat then you decide if you are going to feed that hunger or not. This is will power, simple as that. Perhaps you are ungifted into having a lot of it or you are just apathetic and really don’t want to change, that isn�t my concern and again not relevant to the science of fat loss.

You don’t eat, you get hungry. You exercise, you get hungry. You don’t hydrate yourself enough, and it send signals of thirst that are confused for hunger signals. See, most of the time you are reading thirsty as hungry. Again you just aren’t gifted enough to know how to read your body. At a point you will (if the body is functioning correctly) start to send out peptide signals that silence the hunger pangs. It is much like those who try to quit smoking, you have to hold out on the 10 to 15 minute stabs of cravings and then you will be fine. Again this is your choice, your fate, it is in your hands. Eating oatmeal or a rice krispy treat isn’t going to do much to change this either way.

The Final Conclusion: Good Taubes, Bad Taubes

  • If you are looking for a resource to try and help prove that you are the 1%, then this book is for you!
  • If you are looking for a resource to help back up why the government has it all wrong and not shockingly is trying to manipulate you, the general public, then this book is for you!
  • If you are looking to learn endless study story after study story about why the nutritional pyramid is on crack, then this book is for you!
  • If you are looking for another source to blame something other than yourself for why you aren’t losing fat, then this book is for you!
  • Finally, if you are looking to have a ride on the hate the carb train even though time and again study after study has shown that diet on high carbs can cause you to lose weight if in a caloric deficit but still carbs are evil then you have found your literal best friend!

Sorry folks, the simple truth is and will always be this:

Excess calories cause fat gain.

I may even hit at a Part 3, 4 and even more. For now this is as simple as it gets and as complicated as it should get.

The Fat Loss Troubleshooter – Leigh Peele

Common Sense Meets Advanced Knowledge